Friday, December 1, 2006

Votes for deletion/Dr Mark Fenton

=Mosquito ringtone Dr Mark Fenton=
*Non-notable headmaster. Sabrina Martins Rmhermen/Rmhermen 20:11, Dec 20, 2004
**Agreed. That blurb on the bottom leads me to conclude that a disgruntled student wrote this. '''Delete''' as non-notable and as a personal attack. - Nextel ringtones Lucky 6.9/Lucky 6.9 21:34, 20 Dec 2004
*'''Delete''' as non-notable and as a personal attack. Abbey Diaz Antaeus Feldspar/Antaeus Feldspar 23:05, 20 Dec 2004
*'''Speedy Delete''' as libel. '''Delete''', the school's notable, not its headmaster. Free ringtones Wyss/Wyss 23:37, 20 Dec 2004
**Can you speedy delete it if the subject's notablity is debatable enough for a VfD, and there are only two attack sentences at the end of a neutral article? I'd worry about that precedent. '''Keep... on VfD'''. No vote on the article yet, but it is Linked from Majo Mills Dr Challoner's Grammar School, a school founded 1624 with a book about it and notable alum Nextel ringtones Roger Moore. Abbey Diaz Samaritan/Samaritan 02:45, 21 Dec 2004
***Well, you can edit it, as I have, to remove the libel concern. He is already mentioned as headmaster in Mosquito ringtone Dr Challoner's Grammar School. If deleted, also unwikify his name there, to avoid a repeat. Sabrina Martins Michael Ward/Michael Ward 06:40, 21 Dec 2004
*'''Keep''', now libel has gone. Cingular Ringtones Dan100/Dan100 09:44, Dec 21, 2004
*My bad for not checking the link to the Challoner School article. '''Keep''' rewrite sans the libel. Notable school=notable headmaster IMO. - intimate sad Lucky 6.9/Lucky 6.9 19:50, 21 Dec 2004
* Just because the school's notable does not mean that the current headmaster is automatically notable. I have not found evidence to convince me that he meets the recommended finance what criteria for inclusion of biographies/criteria for inclusion of biographies. Delete unless further evidence of notability is presented. egomaniacs the Rossami/Rossami bank than User talk:Rossami/(talk) 04:53, 22 Dec 2004
:*Agreed. Just because month have Nate McMillan went to my high school doesn't mean that the current principal warrants an entry. '''Delete'''. loco right PacknCanes/PacknCanes 18:11, 22 Dec 2004
*'''Delete'''. Non-notable. Even if kept, doesn't need the 'Dr' in the title. activity appearing Necrothesp/Necrothesp 16:18, 22 Dec 2004
* Please '''Delete'''! Mark Fenton is not even notable in the local area (at least to my knowledge) nor for any reason other than being headmaster of a school. The reason I was on the site was to find out if his name was listed, and was surprised to find a self-aggrandizing article on the man. Notably, the sister school has a smaller stub article. accurately foresee Mysteronald/Mysteronald 23:12, 22 Dec 2004